Bitter Taste For Coffee Shop Owner, As New $600 Jobless Benefit Drove Her To Close

Apr 21, 2020
Originally published on April 21, 2020 4:41 pm

Updated at 4:04 p.m. ET

$600 per week.

That's what the federal government is now offering to people who've lost their jobs because of the coronavirus.

For many workers and employers, that money is a godsend — a way to keep food on the table while also cutting payroll costs.

But the extra money can create some awkward situations. Some businesses that want to keep their doors open say it's hard to do so when employees can make more money by staying home.

"We basically have this situation where it would be a logical choice for a lot of people to be unemployed," said Sky Marietta, who opened a coffee shop along with her husband, Geoff, last year in Harlan, Ky.

Their goal was to provide good coffee, good Internet service and some opportunity in a community that has been starved of all three.

"We're very committed to helping to transform the downtowns and main streets in eastern Kentucky," Marietta said.

When the couple advertised for workers, nearly 100 people applied for just a handful of openings.

The shop had been up and running for only a few months when the coronavirus hit. Marietta adopted precautions, instructing her workers to wash their hands frequently and disinfecting the door handle.

Eventually, she stopped letting customers come into the shop, delivering orders to the curb instead. But Marietta was determined to stay open.

"The No. 1 people that we're serving right now are health care workers," she said. "I feel like they don't have a lot of options, and they certainly deserve at least some coffee in this, right?"

But even though she had customers, Marietta reluctantly decided to close the coffee shop just over a week ago.

"The very people we hired have now asked us to be laid off," Marietta wrote in a blog post. "Not because they did not like their jobs or because they did not want to work, but because it would cost them literally hundreds of dollars per week to be employed."

With the federal government now offering $600 a week on top of the state's unemployment benefits, she recognized her former employees could make more money staying home than they did on the job.

"You also have to think, the benefit of not having to go to work, especially during a pandemic," Marietta said in an interview with NPR. "It's not that we don't wish that we could pay our employees at that level all the time. You're always wanting to pay your staff the best you possible can. But to be put in a position where you can't compete with them being at home, unemployed. It's really tricky. It's a really difficult situation to be in."

Some Republican lawmakers warned about this unintended consequence of the relief bill when it was being drafted, noting that $600 a week amounts to $15 an hour, more than twice the federal minimum wage. That's in addition to state unemployment benefits, which vary widely, from a maximum of $235 per week in Mississippi to $795 per week in Massachusetts.

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin says the administration opted to provide a uniform federal unemployment benefit in order to get money out the door quickly. As it is, states have struggled to pay the benefit to the millions of newly unemployed people who are applying every week.

Many employers have welcomed the federal benefits. Knowing workers have an additional lifeline from the government makes even painful layoffs a little bit easier. Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley highlighted the federal payout during an emotional news conference last month during which he furloughed 1,700 city employees.

"We are taking these dramatic steps now while the federal government is providing these dollars because it will give us the resources we need to bring you back," Cranley said.

Some employers — like the auto industry — have always relied on unemployment benefits as a kind of taxpayer subsidy for workers during slow periods.

"It helps the employer, because otherwise they may feel that they need to pay people more in order to convince them to take these jobs that have this tendency for temporary layoffs," said University of Michigan economist Betsey Stevenson.

But in her Kentucky coffee shop, Marietta wasn't looking for someone to cover the cost of idling her employees. She wanted them to keep working. Unfortunately, she says, the $10 to $15 an hour they'd make serving coffee is no match for the new jobless benefits.

"We have these lovely baristas," Marietta said. "They're hardworking individuals. But literally this is the best possible pay of their lives they could possibly get, to be unemployed."

She worries about what will happen to those workers when the federal unemployment benefits run out at the end of July. Maybe by then, she'll be able to reopen.

Clarification: 4/20/20

In this audio story, as well as in a previous Web version, we do not make it clear that Sky Marietta closed her coffee shop voluntarily so that her employees would qualify for expanded unemployment benefits.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

Six hundred dollars a week - that is what the federal government is now offering to people who have lost their jobs because of the coronavirus. For many workers and employers, that money is a godsend, a way to keep food on the table while also cutting payroll costs. The extra money can create some awkward situations, though. Some businesses that want to keep their doors open say it's hard to do so when employees can make more money by staying home. Here's NPR's Scott Horsley.

SCOTT HORSLEY, BYLINE: When Sky Marietta opened a coffee shop, an Internet cafe, last year in Harlan, Ky., a lot of people wanted to work there. Nearly a hundred applied for just a handful of openings. Harlan is one of the poorest communities in the country, stripped bare of coal mines and opportunity. Sky and her husband Geoff were hoping to change that.

SKY MARIETTA: We're very committed to helping transform the downtowns and main streets in eastern Kentucky.

HORSLEY: The shop had been open for just a few months when the coronavirus hit. Marietta told her workers to wash their hands every time they used the cash register and take their temperature at the start of every shift. Eventually, she stopped letting customers into the shop, instead delivering orders to the curb.

MARIETTA: You have all these different trade-offs to make. Should we stay open? Are they say if it we're open? The same time, you know, the No. 1 people that we're serving right now are health care workers. And I feel like they don't have a lot of options, and they certainly deserve at least some coffee in this, right?

HORSLEY: But even though she had customers, Marietta reluctantly closed the coffee shop just over a week ago. With the federal government now offering $600 a week on top of the state's unemployment benefits, her former employees can make more money staying home than they did on the job.

MARIETTA: We're very committed to paying a living wage. It happens that a living wage in Harlan, Ky., is not exactly the same thing as it is in other parts of the country. We basically have this situation where it would be a logical choice for a lot of people to be unemployed.

HORSLEY: Some Republican lawmakers warned about this when the relief bill was being drafted. They noted that $600 a week amounts to $15 an hour, more than twice the federal minimum wage. On top of that, state unemployment benefits vary widely, from a maximum of $235 a week in Mississippi to $795 a week in Massachusetts. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin says the administration opted for a uniform federal payment to get money out the door quickly. Many employers have welcomed the federal benefits. Knowing workers have a lifeline from the government makes even painful layoffs a little bit easier.

Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley highlighted the benefits during an emotional news conference at which he furloughed 1,700 city employees.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JOHN CRANLEY: In fact, we are taking these dramatic steps now while the federal government is providing these dollars because it will give us the resources we need to bring you back.

HORSLEY: Some employers have always relied on unemployment as a kind of taxpayer subsidy for workers during slow periods. University of Michigan economist Betsey Stevenson says that's been common, for example, in the auto industry.

BETSEY STEVENSON: It helps the employer because, otherwise, they may feel that they need to pay people more in order to convince them to take jobs that have this tendency for temporary layoffs.

HORSLEY: But in Harlan, Ky., Sky Marietta wasn't looking for someone to cover the cost of idling her employees; she wanted them to keep working. Unfortunately, she says, the $10 to $15 an hour they'd make at the coffee shop was no match for the new jobless benefits.

MARIETTA: We have these lovely baristas. They want to work. They're hardworking individuals. But literally, this is the best possible pay of their lives they could possibly get to be unemployed.

HORSLEY: Marietta worries about what will happen to her former employees when the federal unemployment benefits run out at the end of July. Maybe by then she'll be able to reopen.

Scott Horsley, NPR News, Washington.

[POST-BROADCAST CLARIFICATION: In this audio story, we do not make it clear that Sky Marietta closed her coffee shop voluntarily so that her employees would qualify for expanded unemployment benefits.]

(SOUNDBITE OF YEARS OF RICE AND SALT'S "AMONGST YOUR EARTHIEST WORDS THE ANGELS STRAY" Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.